Rated 1 out of 5 by Goodat50 Disappointed for money
Sadly when box was opened and pencil lid removed the eye liner stick fell out of the pencil! A huge disappointment as I've run out of eye liner! Straight on the phone to QVC and a replacement is on the way so hope replacement will be better!
September 22, 2016
Rated 4 out of 5 by chiccassie Decent Sharpener Needed
When I used this for the first time, I thought WOW! The results were great, but as usual with pencil sharpeners the result is only as good as the sharpener, and for that reason the result is never as good as its first use. Would be happy to pay extra for a sharpener with a blade to match the one used in the factory.
September 14, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by Terrysallgold2 LOVE IT
My second Bobbi Brown purchase - the first being the Soho collection and had to have this eyeliner which I have coveted for some time.
I ordered the Midnight Blue and when it arrived, upon opening the eyeliner had come away from the pencil. It was very easy to put back in and I was able to use it. It was so lux, so soft and easy to apply no harsh abrasiveness, and very gentle on the eye, both inside and out, it looked stunning, I was so pleased and I wore it all day and it didn't move until I took it off.
On reading the reviews I noticed that this had happened to another lady and she had replaced her eyeliner, being told that this sometime does happen.
I rang up QVC and spoke to a lovely lady named Karen, and when I told her of my problem and the other review she immediately arranged a replacement for me. She also arranging a pre-paid envelope for me and has reserved a replacement as stocks are low, and all I can say is, Thank you Karen and QVC for your fab service and I really look forward to getting my replacement.
The slight hiccup, which I quite understand, has not put me off this product and I shall be adding the Jet and the Black Plum to me collection in due course.
Finally I would just like t say that the whole QVC experience is a joy. I love the demonstrations by the experts and the presenters and of course the fab Alison Young (BE - not Bare Essentials but Beauty Expert) she is such a scream, together with Will and some of the other experts models and presenters she toys with, she could have her own comedy hour.
The enjoyment of just sitting there and buying, with confidence, seeing the demonstrations and getting advice from the call centre staff , as with the lovely Karen, and the shear joy of opening that parcel is fab.
I nearly forgot the money back guarantee - and of course EASY PAY - WHOOO!
On a horrid rainy day like today, I could quite easily spend the whole time watching the various beauty shows. and really enjoy feeling a part of the QVC community.
February 13, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by Cabbage48 Excellent
Goes on easily, stays on through a swimming session, . In sort, can't beat it.
Does require sharpening a lot but it does the job.
Last one was benefit waterproof eyeliner and it didn't stay on long, this one is perfect.
October 13, 2013
Rated 1 out of 5 by ChloeCat1 Poor quality
Bobbi Brown is usually one of the best ranges. However, not with this eye pencil. It is very soft which is good - and I managed to get one eye lined but as soon as I touched the other eye the liner snapped at the bottom. It's therefore going back as I'm not prepared to keep wasting product like that - especially as I left the liner on to see how it performed and 3 hours later it was gone. Gone where, I don't know but there wasn't a mark left on my eyelid and I hadn't rubbed my eye.
August 12, 2013
Rated 1 out of 5 by Annette123 Oh Dear Bobbi - what have you done!!!
Well anyhone who has ever read my reviews in the past of Bobbi Brown which I have used since she first sold her range here in the UK and I absolutely adore it. You won't hear many criticisms from me about this range - that is until now.
I bought the new style eyeliner pencil, thinking it would be easier for me to use than the pot of gel - how wrong I was - I'm sticking to the longwear gel eyeliner which no other maker has come anywhere close to making as good as the original BB one.
The pencil liner did not stay put as well as the gel in the pot.
So, although i'm going to use it till it's finished - also needs sharpening too frequently and thus would be an expensive item to replace, which if it was worth the effort I would do without question, however it's just not.
Sorry Bobbie and QVC.
July 04, 2013
Rated 2 out of 5 by Blondie1 Not good
I thought I would try this for speed of use as I love the gel and pen liner Bobby does.
This for me is ok on the top lashes, however if you want to use underneath the eye the pencil nib is too thick tried sharpening it but still too thick.
I will not be repurchasing this again, and sticking to the other 2 methods which works fab and is the best.
June 07, 2013
Rated 5 out of 5 by gwestoby Does what it says on the tin
I love this product. I have tried and tested many eye liners and this defiantly lives up to its name.
It's very soft and easy to apply and does not drag the eye, also very easy to blend.
Once dry it does not move unless taken off with a make up remover.
Love, love, love!
June 04, 2013