Rated 1 out of 5 by elm1601 Messy and Goes Dry - LOADS OF WASTAGE!!!
Great for the first use, then after that it dries and you have to waste loads to get it going again (before the new liner comes to the surface). It does stay put all day but VERY difficult to apply. This is for a pro!!
Expensive mistake :(
January 19, 2016
Rated 5 out of 5 by stockport1 Love love love this eye liner!
Surprised to read some of the reviews because I think this eye liner is fab. I have tried lots of gel liners, and I was a fan of the original Bobbi Brown which is a lovely texture. However you get almost the same results with this one from Benefit, but so much easier to apply. It glides on, really true black colour, doesn't leave a trace on your lid when you blink. Easier than using a gel liner with a brush. However it is a little bitty as some have said, you do have to wipe the bits off the wand during application - any tips from the Benefit lady on that would be great. Completely bullet proof - you need a really good eye make up remover to get it off. Hope that help ! Give it a try and see what you think !
January 06, 2016
Rated 1 out of 5 by miracleproductfinder Worst benefit product
I normally love all Benefit products so am surprised this eyeliner is so bad. It is dry and bitty. I have to wipe away the first little bit every time I use it as it has dried out overnight, so very wasteful, even though the top is replaced. It doesn't go on smoothly. Bits flake off as I am trying to get it on....not a good look. Maybe its for a younger eyelid that doesn't pucker as you try and get it on. The one plus is that it does stay on all day. I won't be purchasing this again, I will stick with Bobbi Brown gel eyeliner.
November 03, 2015
Rated 1 out of 5 by ArtDeco27 So Disappointed!
I was so disappointed with this product.
Contrary to what was stated on the presentation, it is NOT easy to apply, it DOES drag across the eye. It definitely DOES smudge and budge. It also cakes, I also had dry lumps coming off the liner and not just once, but every time I used it and twisted the top to release the tint.
I have used it a number of times to give it a proper test and also because I wanted it to work to badly.
Finally, I now have an itchy reaction to the liner, I have never had a reaction to makeup before.
All in all a complete disaster!!
September 04, 2015
Rated 1 out of 5 by lou12 what liner ?
Looked on here to get the product out tube . 5 6 7 clicks ,still no eyeliner . don't buy . thank you reviews .
August 13, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by cherylge Actually stays put
I must be the eyeliner queen, I've tried so many to try and find one that stays. Even so called waterproof ones seem to end up smudged round my eyes, that I end up looking like a reject from the rocky horror show. Received this the other day and was amazed at the ease with which goes on, even a novice could manage a decent flick with this applicator. But more importantly, it stays! Even in this warm weather, it is still there at 7 in the evening. If you were going out from work you might want to reapply for a sharper finish, the colour I chose was green and its just dark enough but obvious too. Love it, if I can do it, and I wear reading glasses, most people should be able to. Try it, it's GOOD!
June 30, 2015
Rated 1 out of 5 by Poshnails Very Disappointed
Had been looking forward to getting this liner as recently tried their new mascara and was thrilled with that. Like other reviews I found this so difficult to apply, it just "blobs" out and try as I might I could not get it to go on smoothly. It has great staying power which is no good when it cannot be applied in a smooth line. Works well on the back of the hand though! Sorry had to return it.
May 24, 2015
Rated 4 out of 5 by CassiniDivision Great Product but little cap could be improved
This is a great product - staying power is amazing. To use this product you have to squeeze some out on the back of your hand to work with. If you put it straight onto your lid, you get blobs as it doesn't flow evenly.
Using this method (dipping product from the back of your hand), it does a great and v quick straight line. It does an even better smoky eye - draw a line on your upper lash line and then take a small brush and smudge the product away from the lash line just a little, in the direction of your brow - Bobbi Brown style. Beware you need some serious makeup remover to get it off your hand though!
My one criticism is the design of the little orange cap that seals the pen when you are not using it - it is tiny and difficult to plug back in. I worry it will get lost and that that would lead to leaks or the product drying up.
May 03, 2015